• @Ilovethebomb
    link
    -710 months ago

    Restore Passenger Rail spokesman James Cockle told media the group’s demands are for affordable nationwide passenger rail and free urban public transport.

    What do these people have against buses? We have a fairly decent intercity bus network, which is affordable and reasonably fast, in fact faster than the train in most cases. Let rail handle freight, it’s what rail does well.

    In addition to being out of touch with reality, this is also not how you get people to support your cause.

    • @ciaocibai
      link
      5
      edit-2
      10 months ago

      Yeah busses are potentially part of the solution, but decent rail connections can be more disruptive (positively) over longer distances e.g Welly - Palmy, Auckland - Hamilton etc.

      Having previously lived in China and experiencing the amazing train network there I definitely see the benefits of a solid rail system. Way more efficient than busses too.

      Nuts to me that places like Wellington had pretty good electric bus systems with trolley busses but replaced them largely with diesel. Not sure what the bus fleet is like now though.

      Also not sure why you are being downvoted for a pretty reasonable discussion.

      • @Ilovethebomb
        link
        010 months ago

        Reddit is fucking weird about trains, and it looks like that has filtered over to here.

        Our bus fleet is mostly battery electric now.

        • @Rangelus
          link
          210 months ago

          Didn’t all the trolley busses get scrapped in favor of Diesel some time ago?

          • @Ilovethebomb
            link
            110 months ago

            The plan was to replace them with battery electric buses, with the diesels being a stop-gap measure.

            To nobody’s surprise, the new buses took a lot longer to arrive than expected, but they are mostly there.

            • @Rangelus
              link
              210 months ago

              Ah nice. It’s been a while I’ve been in Welly, so I wasn’t sure what the current status is.

    • @Ozymati
      link
      410 months ago

      I think they want rail between suburbs and cities. Definitely if there was rail direct from Porirua to Lower Hutt a huge amount of people who live in one place would suddenly be willing to work in the other, or vice versa.

      • @Ilovethebomb
        link
        -210 months ago

        They probably would, but that would be ridiculously expensive, as it would require extensive tunnelling.

        I’ve read some of their demands, mostly they want the old level of intercity services restored. Which, as I’ve already said, is currently served quite well by bus services.

        • @liv
          link
          110 months ago

          Bus services in the regions seem to have really nosedived since covid.