Great write-up.

In fact, the line “Labour and National had broadly similar fiscal approaches…” is worth repeating.

So the default position we should be applying to the current government is – where is all the evidence for the claims that Luxon is making?

  • @deadbeef79000
    cake
    link
    84 months ago

    It’s FUD.

    We can’t find tax cuts for the ultra wealthy unless we penny pinch welfare.

    • @thevoyagekayaking
      link
      14 months ago

      Their tax cuts, or more accurately bracket adjustments, will mean more money for almost everyone in NZ. Where did this “ultra wealthy” thing come from?

      • @Xcf456
        link
        64 months ago

        Their tax cuts, or more accurately bracket adjustments, will mean more money for almost everyone in NZ

        It absolutely will not. People on low incomes get nothing, people on low to middle get $2 a week, only around 3000 families meet the highly specific targeted criteria for the $250 per fortnight that was misleadingly flashed around during the election. The rest goes to upper incomes and that’s before the landlord handouts.

        Then a whole bunch of these people will be directly financially worse off from removal of public transport and prescription support, big rates increases from abandoning 3 waters with no replacement and so on and so on.

      • @TagMeInSkipIGotThis
        link
        5
        edit-2
        4 months ago

        Don’t hold your breath on the bracket adjustments actually happening; the only ones that are certain to go through are the back dated landlord subsidies.

        • @thevoyagekayaking
          link
          04 months ago

          Yeah, the fuckers are already trying to squirm out of that one.

          The inflationary adjustment is something I support the principle of more than anything else, but it’s a disappointing start for sure.

          On a slightly related topic, it was incredible watching Labour’s support collapse last election, wasn’t it?

          • @TagMeInSkipIGotThis
            link
            14 months ago

            The principle sounds good & common sense like. But I believe NZ is vastly under taxed - compared to the public services we clearly want & need. So anything that reduces the tax take is for me a big negative. The only way i’d support the inflation adjustment to the brackets is by countering it with CGT and wealth taxes; and i’d also couple that with reducing GST as well.

            • @thevoyagekayaking
              link
              14 months ago

              Labour really should have gotten a CGT in while they had the chance, and an absolute majority. In my view, their failure to make the most of that is why they did so poorly in the last election.

              In terms of a wealth tax, I don’t like the idea one bit, mostly because I believe that once you have bought something, especially a property, it should be yours to keep. If your primary dwelling was exempt from the tax, then I would look at the proposal a bit more seriously.

              Otherwise, you make life hard for retirees etc.

              • @TagMeInSkipIGotThis
                link
                24 months ago

                I don’t think that way about property. I think it would be better to think about property as a right to use; and once you’re not using it, or not able to use it to its fullest that right should revert back to the community. Life’s only hard for retirees because we choose to leave people to the luck of what they accumulated during their life time. We could choose to take care of everyone if we wanted to.

              • @Xcf456
                link
                14 months ago

                Otherwise, you make life hard for retirees etc.

                The wealth tax the Greens propose is specifically designed to mitigate this, as it wouldnt apply to the first $2 million net for individuals and $4 million net for couples.

                • @thevoyagekayaking
                  link
                  14 months ago

                  They did think of that, but what are the chances that figure will be adjusted for inflation?

      • @RangelusOP
        link
        54 months ago

        The amount of extra money the average earner will get is negligible, while the amount of public services that are getting cut to lay for it will leave most people worse off in the long run.

  • @TagMeInSkipIGotThis
    link
    74 months ago

    Gordon Campbell has been putting out brilliant articles for years now (decades probably!). He’s got a bias that appeals to me, but is very fact based in his analysis so its hard to dispute what he’s describing, perhaps some could argue against what his suggested actions are.

  • @BalpeenHammer
    link
    14 months ago

    Do you expect honesty, empathy or goodwill from them?

    • @liv
      link
      24 months ago

      I think we can still be critical of things without being surprised by them.