Tad hysterical, don’t you think?

College of Public Health Medicine president Sir Collin Tukuitonga has said the reversal of the smokefree amendments would result in about 1000 extra deaths over the next decade, mostly Māori, and cost the health system $1.3 billion.

Calling that a “genocide” is a bit ridiculous.

  • @IlovethebombOP
    link
    -17 months ago

    I actually think if Labour had toned down a lot of their policies, they wouldn’t be getting them repealed now. If they’d continued with the increased excise, and perhaps reduced the number of outlets that can sell them, the law would have stuck around.

    • @liv
      link
      47 months ago

      Maybe. I’m not convinced this particular repeal was due to majority/popular demand.

      The only campaign I ever saw about repealing turned out to be astroturfing by a tobacco company pretending to be a dairy owner.

      It seems way more like the sort of thing Seymour and ACT would be interested in. So I think it was a coalition agreement issue. Here’s my reasoning:

      The average voter isn’t affected by the law change personally so the only point of repealing it would be to fight for your children to smoke tobacco. Parents mostly don’t especially want their own kids to risk lung cancer, and it’s also not a tangible improvement to communities.

      That leaves fighting for it as a matter of ideological principle. I.e ACT.

      • @IlovethebombOP
        link
        37 months ago

        Winnie has made some surprisingly pro smoking statements during his career, so he would likely have been on board as well.

        • @liv
          link
          27 months ago

          Good point, it could even originate with him - I saw someone saying Winston has links with tobacco companies. Not sure how true that is.

          Also Winston himself smokes. If he is using transfusions from blood boys or something to stay immortal, maybe he needs them to be able to smoke too?

          • @IlovethebombOP
            link
            37 months ago

            using transfusions from blood boys or something

            That would explain a lot actually.