i bet they do now, but i’ve checked back now and then, and all of my comments and posts are most assuredly gone.
edit: i’ve gone back to check some old haunts, place i know i’ve commented, and i did some seaching with google using my old usernames, as google uses its cache to match to the posts\comments, even though they’re not there any more.
i see old posts that are graveyards of deleted comments, some with simply deleted accounts, and many others where both the account and comment are deleted. i don’t see any gibberish comments. the ones i know are mine (because replies quote the comment above, which i recognize as mine), are all just deleted in their entirety, so it seems they didn’t do comment versioning, at least not past the first edit. i see no posts under any former username of mine.
the efforts to scrub my content from reddit last May appears to have worked. sadly, since the API lockdown, those tools no longer work.
Just because it shows [deleted] doesn’t mean the data were deleted. That is most likely just a flag for the comment.
They most likely keep every save since they decided to do the sell the data thing. Why would google pay them for what google could easily scrape other than having the full history?
As I mentioned, I overwrote the comments several times before deleting them. I seriously doubt that they saved multiple versions of the comments. I know that, towards the end of May, they made some backend changes to try to circumvent users attempt to delete their accounts, but I did all of this to my account a couple of weeks before that.
No, I think the other commenter is right. They definitely store every version of every comment on their backend. Just because it’s not displayed publicly doesn’t mean they don’t have the data.
That literally means nothing at all on their server backup from the year before. You could delete and rewrite your comments a thousand times and it would do you the same amount as good as one time, and barely any better than doing it no times at all. Your entire 15 year comment history would take up probably 10MB of space at best. They’ll have several back ups taken over the last decade. They aren’t just going to be selling off the live servers info.
I imagine that they would. Text is trivially easy to store, and storing multiple versions would let them catch users who might edit away rule breaking they posted to avoid bans, but it’s probably one of those internal tools.
From a data handling perspective, it’d be more efficient to handle edits by having a common id field, and an additional version/edit counter that increments --adding the edit like its a normal post-- , than it would be to edit data the usual way, since you don’t have to go back over the whole database to find the comment, or worry about it falling out of sync if one copy of the database has the edit, and the other has the original.
You’d just need to fetch the comment by id, and the database entry with the highest version count to display it, which would be fairly easy to do.
if you request your data from them under CCPA, and it shows the edited comments as gibberish, you’re good. I did the same thing but I left the comments to simmer for a long time like months.
If you request your data, which they do have the option for, you will unfortunately see that a lot of your comments were preserved. But I did comb through it, and a good chunk of mine were successfully replaced with the gibberish.
Unfortunately, if you actually deleted your account, there is nothing you can do to access that data. I’m pretty sure we both ran the same script - “nuke Reddit.“ I ran it probably every four months for a few years and then I ran it several times right before the API change. I can tell you with certainty that some of your comments are still there. I also ran that one everyone recommended during the API fiasco but I can’t remember its name.
That being said, you probably we’re able to knock out a lot of it. I wouldn’t worry too much about it. We’re lucky we can even do that much. Most social media sites you can’t get rid of anything no matter how hard you try.
Feel good knowing that they aren’t getting a single cent more out of you
I did do it a couple of weeks before the API policy change, so I have a bit more confidence that they were really deleted. I know that they made some backend changes right before the API policy change, which prevented such actions from being permanent. I really did go back and look through past posts in past comments even from many years back, and my comments really are very much gone. Sure, I can’t go and see all tens of thousands of them, but spot checking from a year ago all the way back to nine or 10 years ago, they’re all gone wherever I’ve looked.
But you’re right, they are not going to get one more cent out of me, in time or effort. Thank goodness I never actually gave them any real money.
i bet they do now, but i’ve checked back now and then, and all of my comments and posts are most assuredly gone.
edit: i’ve gone back to check some old haunts, place i know i’ve commented, and i did some seaching with google using my old usernames, as google uses its cache to match to the posts\comments, even though they’re not there any more.
i see old posts that are graveyards of deleted comments, some with simply deleted accounts, and many others where both the account and comment are deleted. i don’t see any gibberish comments. the ones i know are mine (because replies quote the comment above, which i recognize as mine), are all just deleted in their entirety, so it seems they didn’t do comment versioning, at least not past the first edit. i see no posts under any former username of mine.
the efforts to scrub my content from reddit last May appears to have worked. sadly, since the API lockdown, those tools no longer work.
Just because it shows [deleted] doesn’t mean the data were deleted. That is most likely just a flag for the comment.
They most likely keep every save since they decided to do the sell the data thing. Why would google pay them for what google could easily scrape other than having the full history?
As I mentioned, I overwrote the comments several times before deleting them. I seriously doubt that they saved multiple versions of the comments. I know that, towards the end of May, they made some backend changes to try to circumvent users attempt to delete their accounts, but I did all of this to my account a couple of weeks before that.
No, I think the other commenter is right. They definitely store every version of every comment on their backend. Just because it’s not displayed publicly doesn’t mean they don’t have the data.
That literally means nothing at all on their server backup from the year before. You could delete and rewrite your comments a thousand times and it would do you the same amount as good as one time, and barely any better than doing it no times at all. Your entire 15 year comment history would take up probably 10MB of space at best. They’ll have several back ups taken over the last decade. They aren’t just going to be selling off the live servers info.
I imagine that they would. Text is trivially easy to store, and storing multiple versions would let them catch users who might edit away rule breaking they posted to avoid bans, but it’s probably one of those internal tools.
From a data handling perspective, it’d be more efficient to handle edits by having a common
idfield, and an additional version/edit counter that increments --adding the edit like its a normal post-- , than it would be to edit data the usual way, since you don’t have to go back over the whole database to find the comment, or worry about it falling out of sync if one copy of the database has the edit, and the other has the original.You’d just need to fetch the comment by id, and the database entry with the highest version count to display it, which would be fairly easy to do.
if you request your data from them under CCPA, and it shows the edited comments as gibberish, you’re good. I did the same thing but I left the comments to simmer for a long time like months.
If you request your data, which they do have the option for, you will unfortunately see that a lot of your comments were preserved. But I did comb through it, and a good chunk of mine were successfully replaced with the gibberish.
i mean… i overwrite them 3 times. and, before deleting the account, i verified that they’d been overwritten multiple times. and they’re all gone now.
exactly how would i go about requesting that data anyway? my accounts have been deleted.
Unfortunately, if you actually deleted your account, there is nothing you can do to access that data. I’m pretty sure we both ran the same script - “nuke Reddit.“ I ran it probably every four months for a few years and then I ran it several times right before the API change. I can tell you with certainty that some of your comments are still there. I also ran that one everyone recommended during the API fiasco but I can’t remember its name.
That being said, you probably we’re able to knock out a lot of it. I wouldn’t worry too much about it. We’re lucky we can even do that much. Most social media sites you can’t get rid of anything no matter how hard you try.
Feel good knowing that they aren’t getting a single cent more out of you
I did do it a couple of weeks before the API policy change, so I have a bit more confidence that they were really deleted. I know that they made some backend changes right before the API policy change, which prevented such actions from being permanent. I really did go back and look through past posts in past comments even from many years back, and my comments really are very much gone. Sure, I can’t go and see all tens of thousands of them, but spot checking from a year ago all the way back to nine or 10 years ago, they’re all gone wherever I’ve looked.
But you’re right, they are not going to get one more cent out of me, in time or effort. Thank goodness I never actually gave them any real money.
I ran it multiple times a year for years man :/
The data request shows comments/posts you can’t find anymore as a user.